Colonising Mutton Cove for AUKUS

In the last two weeks, heavy machinery and high vis personnel have begun the process of claiming the southern end of Mutton Cove, for infrastructure for AUKUS. Mutton Cove now lies between the Sub Corp, at the southern end, and the new precinct for building nuclear submarines in the north, on the Lefevre Peninsula in Adelaide. Behind this development is a story of disregard for the local environment and bad faith behaviour by Commonwealth and State governments.

For many years Mutton Cove was understood to be the Mutton Cove Conservation Reserve, and bore signs indicating that; it was disappointing to later learn that that the State Government had not approved Reserve status.

Decades ago Mutton Cove was slated for development, which never came, so there began a long process of re-establishing Mutton Cove as a wetland, with saltmarsh habitat and a tidal creek lined by mangroves. That work was undone when the State Government failed to maintain the seawall along the Port River, and it was breached in 2016. The future of Mutton Cove has been unclear since then. Australian Naval Infrastructure (ANI) in 2021 organised co-funding, from ANI, Flinders Ports, the City of Port Adelaide Enfield and the SA Department of Environment, for an analysis of coastal risks and identification of adaptation options. However the report has never been publicly released, and no repairs have been undertaken.

Approximately eight years ago, Friends of Port River (FPR) and Port Adelaide Residents Environment Protection Group (PAREPG) were approached by ANI to meet regularly with them, as part of their efforts to secure a social licence. Those meetings became monthly, when AUKUS was announced, and then included the Australian Submarine Agency (ASA), and later the Department of Premier and Cabinet.

Throughout those eight years FPR and PAREPG have highlighted the importance of Mutton Cove, and Biodiversity Park, to our local environment and community. In June 2025, FPR and PAREPG were advised that there was an EPBC Referral 2025/10202 for the Osborne Utilities Relocation Project, involving the relocation of 2 high-pressure subsurface gas transmission pipelines (Epic and SEA Gas), the relocation of high voltage (275 kilovolt) overhead power lines managed by ElectraNet and the expansion of the existing Lefevre Substation and decommissioning of overhead electricity transmission line towers. FPR and PAREPG were never advised that on 26/11/2025 the project was withdrawn.

By withdrawing from the EPBC assessment, the trenching for the gas lines was treated under State legislation as “essential infrastructure” with no process of public consultation (though Epic Energy did advise stakeholders and some saltmarsh was relocated). The process for State assessment of the new ElectraNet substation and trenching is outlined below.

During 2026, FPR and PAREPG were briefly advised at the monthly meetings that an expansion was proposed of the substation within Mutton Cove, into the adjacent carpark. The full scale of the impact on Mutton Cove only became apparent when a Development Application was lodged, and FPR and PAREPG saw the footprint for the new ElectraNet substation and the nature and extent of the trenching by ElectraNet, plus Epic Energy and SEAGas through Mutton Cove.

FPR and PAREPG then had two weeks (from July 22nd) to lodge submissions about our concerns to the State Assessment Commission Panel (SCAP). Both ANI and DHUD (advising SCAP) indicated that no referral was required to the Commonwealth under the EPBC Act, and there was no mention of a referral having been lodged and withdrawn in 2025. No environmental assessment (beyond assessments of regulated and significant trees) was provided to SCAP and this was accepted. These are the notes informing FPR’s presentation (5 minutes allowed) to SCAP on October 14th.

Minister Champion approved the development on 23rd October 2026. There’s no requirement to make public if or how the Conditions of approval are met, and no guarantee that they will be met, including re-vegetation.

The Minister has approved Condition 8 fully aware that the new substation will not meet the Coast Protection Board’s minimum finished floor levels: “Where minimum finished floor levels are not achieved, all mechanical, chemical and electrical equipment vulnerable to water ingress shall be raised to a minimum level of 3.55 metres AHD.” That’s in the context of a failing seawall along the Port River!

(Note: FPR subsequently withdrew from the monthly liaison meetings)